Who Will Be the Diamondbacks Starting Catcher in 2026? Gabriel Moreno or Jame McCann?

In 2025, Gabriel Moreno saw his playing time behind the plate reduced as James McCann assumed a larger role for the Diamondbacks, especially down the stretch. We break down why Moreno didn’t catch as much, comparing offensive stats, defensive metrics, and their overall impact on the pitching staff. We also discuss Gabi’s youth and upside versus McCann’s veteran experience and durability—and what it could mean for Arizona’s catcher situation in 2026.

On top of that, there are four elimination games in the Divisional Series today that we’re excited to watch, plus some fun parenting news: Josh Naylor becoming a dad and Derek Jeter skipping a Parent-Teacher Conference during Tuesday’s rain delay.

Why Diamondbacks Should Bring Back James McCann as Backup Catcher

0:00 – Intro

2:30 – MLB Playoffs Are Getting SERIOUS

6:10 – Josh Naylor Baby Update!

7:50 – Are the Cubs Done???

10:25 – Yankees Fans Boo ‘Oh Canada’…

14:30 – Predictions for Tonight

19:30 – James McCann Vs Gabriel Moreno – The Defense

39:40 – James McCann Vs Gabriel Moreno – The Offense

48:40 – Derek Jeter Missed His Kids’ Parent Teacher Conference!